- The Tooth Fairy - The leader. Drives the Tooth Car. Proficient in dental magic.
- Bite Boi - A cool kid with a backwards cap and a skateboard with teeth for wheels. The heart of the group.
- Dr. Floss - Uses her science know-how to store the squad's collected teeth. Wields a minty floss lasso.
- Chompodile- The muscle. Uses his powerful martial abilities to extract teeth.
- Toothchard - The squad's financial expert. Utilizes his accounting expertise to help keep the Molar Mates out of jail.
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.